The Wright/Smithsonian Controversy
Maintaining the Flow
of
Misinformation
 

  BACK    Home    History Wing    Adventure Wing    Exhibits & Programs    Company Store    Information Desk    NEXT 



Entrance  

History Wing  

A History    
of the Airplane 

The Wright/     Smithsonian    
Controversy 

   Up       

 The Flight    
of The Langley    
 Aerodrome
 

Patents and    
Politics 

Aerodrome    
Beginnings 

Rebuilding    
a Reputation 

Jump-Starting    
The Langley    
Laboratory 

An Idea Whose    
Time Had Come 

Making the    
Aerodrome    
Airworthy 

The Patent Pool 

  Maintaining    
The Flow of    
Misinformation 
(You are here.)         

Return Fire 

Resolution 

Down      

First Airplane    
Capable of Flight 

             

Need to    

find your    

 bearings?    

Try these    
navigation aids:    

 Site Map 

Museum Index 

Search    
the Museum
 

 If this is your first    
visit, please stop by:     

About    
the Museum
 

Something to share?     
 Please:     

Contact Us 

            

  Available in Française, Español, Português, Deutsch, Россию, 中文, 日本, and others.
 

hroughout these events, the Smithsonian stuck to its version of the Aerodrome test flights. There was a need to do so. Fiscally conservative members of Congress and the military were being dragged reluctantly into the twentieth century where wars were decided by weapons as much as tactics. A good national defense strategy had to include a heavy investment in technology. The performance of the Langley Aerodrome had become central to a much larger conversation that the country was having about the role of the government in the advance of science and technology. It was counterproductive for someone to point at “Langley’s Folly” as an example of an investment that didn’t pay off. More important, for the Smithsonian to admit that they had misrepresented the facts of the Hammondsport trials would be as much of an embarrassment as the 1903 failure of the Aerodrome.

In August of 1915, Albert Zahm published “The First Man-Carrying Aeroplane Capable of Sustained Free Flight: Langley’s Success as a Pioneer in Aviation” in the Annual Smithsonian Report for 1914. Zahm mentioned the two separate goals of the project, and also claimed that the first goal – the vindication of Langley – was accomplished May 28 through June 5 “…with the Langley aeroplane, kept as nearly as possible in its original condition.” He mentioned some of the changes, but the implication was that these were made during the second phase of the project as Curtiss was investigating the tandem configuration. In the last sentence, he claimed that Langley "developed and built the first many-carrying aircraft capable of sustained free flight."

As fate would have it, Zahm's paper appeared in the Annual Report right after a paper by Orville Wright entitled, "The Stability of Airplanes." In it , Orville described the science behind the new Wright "automatic stabilizer" –  the first autopilot – for which he was awarded the Collier Trophy for aeronautics on 3 February 1914. Orville and Wilbur had worked together on the stabilizer since 1905. With Wilbur now deceased, this achievement was the last fruit of one of the world's most dynamic and prolific partnerships. For the Smithsonian to use this same publication to claim for itself the Wrights' most important and hard-won accomplishment must have hurt the surviving brother to his core.

Similar reports and papers appeared in the Annual Reports of 1915 through 1918.The spin in these articles began appearing in popular magazines, books, and encyclopedias. The 1917 edition of Jane’s All the World’s Aircraft, in its “Historical Aircraft” section, listed the Langley Aerodrome as capable of flight. In another example, the May-October 1915 edition of St. Nicholas, a popular magazine for children, an article “What Every One Should Know About Aeroplanes” opened with a photo of the Langley Aerodrome at Lake Keuka and explained “…the vindication of this great pioneer’s work was accomplished… when Mr. Glenn Curtiss flew the selfsame machine, repaired of course, over Lake Keuka eleven years later.”

In 1918, the Smithsonian restored the Aerodrome A to its original 1903 configuration and hung it in the Arts and Industries Building. The original label simply identified the airplane, but this was soon replaced with one that read, “The first man-carrying aeroplane in the history of the world capable of sustained free flight. Invented, built, and tested over the Potomac River by Samuel Pierpont Langley in 1903. Successfully flown at Hammondsport, N.Y., June 2, 1914.” Up until now Orville had held his tongue, thinking that any public comment from him might be misinterpreted. “A denial of these statements by me might have been looked upon by the public as a jealous attack upon the work of a man who was dead,” Orville later explained. But the Aerodrome exhibit was too much. With the help of his friends, Orville began to fight back.

In Their Own Words


Dr. Albert Zahm in a Curtiss Model D. After the 1914 trials of the Langley Aerodrome, Zahm remained in Curtiss's employ for a short time.

The opening page of "What Everybody Needs to Know About the Aeroplane" from St. Nicholas magazine in 1915.

The Langley "Aerodrome A," restored to its original 1903 configuration and hanging in the Smithsonian's Arts and Industries Building.

The Manly-Balzer engine that had powered the Aerodrome eventually became an exhibit in its own right.

Back to the top

  BACK    Home    History Wing    Adventure Wing    Exhibits & Programs    Company Store    Information Desk    NEXT 

"Aviation is proof that – given the will – we can do the impossible."
 Eddie Rickenbacker

 

 

History of the Airplane/The Wright Brothers-Smithsonian Controversy/Smithsonian Spreads Misinformation

 

www.wright-brothers.org
Copyright © 1999-2014